Methodology
How we assess a boat and its crew
Every vessel, crew and operational plan is scored against a fixed rubric before it carries our guests.
In short
A service must score at least 90 out of 100 against this rubric to be certified as part of our fleet. Failure on safety results in immediate disqualification.
- Safety and regulatory compliance carries 45% of the weighting.
- Vessel quality and guest comfort, 25%.
- Crew professionalism 20%, sustainability and local impact 10%.
01 — The scoring rubric
What gets checked, and what it is worth
Minimum passing score: 90 out of 100.
1. Safety & regulatory compliance — 45%
Vessel seaworthiness
Annual survey reports, hull integrity, engine maintenance logs serviced by authorised dealers, valid registration
15 pts
Onboard safety equipment
SOLAS-grade life jackets for 110% of passenger capacity, serviced life rafts, EPIRB, VHF radio, GPS, fire suppression
15 pts
Crew certification & training
Captain's licence (minimum ANT V), engineer's licence (ATT), Basic Safety Training for all crew, emergency drill records
10 pts
Operational protocols
Documented emergency action plan, real-time BMKG weather checks, strict passenger capacity limits
5 pts
2. Vessel quality & guest comfort — 25%
Engine & performance
Modern multi-engine setups for redundancy; engine hours, noise and fuel efficiency assessed
10 pts
Cleanliness & maintenance
Seating, decks and restrooms; no rust, damage or disrepair
5 pts
Seating & amenities
Cushioned seating, shade, freshwater rinse, secure luggage storage, charging ports
5 pts
Ride stability
Hull design and vessel size appropriate for the Badung Strait
5 pts
3. Crew professionalism & service — 20%
Captain's experience
Verifiable experience on the specific route, with knowledge of currents, hazards and safe anchorages
10 pts
Hospitality & communication
English proficiency, clear pre-departure safety briefings, professional manner
5 pts
Punctuality & efficiency
On-time record, efficient luggage and boarding handling
5 pts
4. Sustainability & local impact — 10%
Environmental and community standards
Responsible operation and positive contribution to the local community
10 pts
Keep reading
Related pages
- Editorial Standards How we research and verify
- About — Bali To Nusa Penida Our mission and values
- Our Team Who carries out the assessment
- The Definitive Guide Maritime law and certification on this route
- Choosing a Safe Boat Operator What to check yourself
- Book your crossing Fares, ports and departures
